Home / Resources / Understanding Child Custody
Understanding Child Custody in West Virginia
When parents live apart, West Virginia law provides a process for deciding where a child lives and who makes important decisions on the child's behalf. Here is a plain-language look at how that process generally works.
Custody, Parenting Plans, and What the Words Mean
Many people use the word "custody" to describe who a child lives with and who makes decisions for them. West Virginia law has moved away from that single word. Instead, the state's domestic relations statute talks about the "allocation of custodial responsibility" and requires a written "parenting plan" in any case involving a minor child.
The change in terminology reflects a change in approach. Rather than awarding "custody" to one parent as a single, all-or-nothing status, the law asks a court to divide specific responsibilities between the parents: caring for the child day to day, and making major decisions on the child's behalf. In everyday conversation, most people, including many attorneys, still say "custody" as shorthand for the same general idea.
Key Terms
- Custodial Responsibility
- The general term West Virginia law uses instead of custody, describing the caretaking and decision-making duties a parent has for a child.
- Parenting Plan
- A written document, approved by the court, that spells out each parent's schedule with the child and how decisions about the child will be made.
Two Kinds of Responsibility: Decisions and Day-to-Day Care
West Virginia law separates parental responsibility into two broad categories. The first is decision-making responsibility, meaning who has the authority to make major decisions about a child's education, medical care, and religious upbringing. The second is the parenting time schedule, meaning where the child physically is and which parent is responsible for the child's routine care at a given time.
A parenting plan can divide these responsibilities in different ways. Parents may share major decisions jointly, or one parent may have final say in a particular area, such as medical decisions, while other decisions are shared. Minor, day-to-day choices, like what a child eats for dinner or what time they go to bed, generally belong to whichever parent has the child at that time.
Key Terms
- Decision-Making Responsibility
- Authority over major, long-term decisions for a child, such as schooling, health care, and religious upbringing.
- Caretaking Functions
- The everyday tasks of raising a child, such as feeding, transportation, and supervision, that a parenting plan divides between parents.
How a Parenting Plan Gets Created
In every West Virginia family court case involving a minor child, whether it arises from a divorce or from parents who were never married, the parents are required to submit a parenting plan. If both parents agree on how time and decisions should be divided, they can submit a single joint plan for the court's approval. Courts generally favor an agreed plan, as long as it appears to have been entered into knowingly and does not put the child at risk.
If the parents cannot agree, each may submit a separate proposed plan. Family courts commonly refer disputed cases to mediation, a process where a neutral third party helps parents try to work out their differences, before scheduling a hearing. When no agreement is possible, a family court judge reviews the evidence from both parents and decides the terms of the parenting plan.
The Starting Point: A Presumption of Equal Parenting Time
Under current West Virginia law, courts start from the presumption that equal, fifty-fifty parenting time is in a child's best interest. That presumption can be challenged. Either parent may present evidence to show that something other than an equal division better serves the particular child in the case.
When a parent successfully challenges the equal-time presumption, the court does not simply hand the child to one parent. Instead, the judge is directed to build a schedule that keeps as much time as reasonably possible with each parent, while still protecting the child's welfare, unless the parents themselves agree to something different.
What the Court Looks At
"Best interest of the child" is the standard that guides custody-related decisions in West Virginia, but it is not a vague, open-ended idea. The law directs courts to weigh specific factors, including which parent performed the greater share of caretaking duties in the period before the parents separated, whether the child has a meaningful relationship with each parent, and whether keeping siblings together is appropriate.
Courts also consider practical realities: how far apart the parents live, each parent's work schedule, and whether the parents are able to cooperate with one another. Where there is credible evidence of domestic violence, substance abuse, or child abuse or neglect, a court can limit or place conditions on a parent's time with the child, such as requiring supervised visits.
A child's own preference can matter as well. A child who is fourteen or older can express a preference about parenting time, and the court is required to consider it. A younger child's preference may also be considered if the child is mature enough, though it generally carries less weight, and courts try not to put a child in the position of feeling that they have to choose between parents.
Can a Parenting Plan Be Changed Later?
A parenting plan is not necessarily permanent. As children grow and family circumstances change, for example, a parent relocates, a work schedule shifts, or a child's needs change, either parent can ask the court to modify the plan. Courts generally look for a significant change in circumstances since the last order before making changes, so that children are not subjected to constant relitigation of their schedule.
Common Questions
Is custody still a legally accurate term in West Virginia?
Not technically. West Virginia's statute now uses the term "allocation of custodial responsibility" and requires a "parenting plan" rather than awarding "custody." In everyday conversation, though, most people, including courts and attorneys, still use "custody" as an informal shorthand for the same general idea.
Does equal parenting time mean exactly half the days, every week?
Not necessarily. Equal parenting time refers to the overall balance of time a child spends with each parent. That balance can be reached through several different schedules, such as alternating weeks or a repeating pattern of several days with each parent, as long as the overall split is roughly even.
What happens if the parents cannot agree on a parenting plan?
If parents cannot agree, each generally submits a proposed plan of their own. The court will often refer the case to mediation first. If mediation does not resolve the disagreement, a family court judge hears evidence from both parents and decides the terms of the plan.
Can a child choose which parent to live with?
A child's preference is a factor the court considers, and it carries more weight as a child gets older, with children fourteen and older entitled to have their preference considered. It is not the only factor, and courts weigh it alongside the child's overall best interest.
Can a parenting plan be changed after the court approves it?
Yes. Either parent can ask the court to modify a parenting plan later if circumstances have changed significantly since it was put in place. Courts generally do not revisit a plan over minor disagreements, since children benefit from stability.
This article is provided for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Laws change, and individual circumstances vary. If you have questions about how West Virginia law applies to your situation, consult a licensed attorney.